The Puerto Rican Holiday Menu - Revised

The Menu Flip

Instead of arroz con gandules swimming in oil, what about a lighter wild rice pilaf with gandules, cranberries, and toasted almonds?
Instead of frying everything in lard, try roasting, searing, or grilling with olive oil, herbs, and fresh citrus.
Pasteles? Keep the tradition, but maybe make a smaller batch, paired with a refined appetizer spread of seafood ceviche or roasted veggie tapas.
And dessert—swap the over-sweet tres leches for a refined flan de coco with shaved dark chocolate. Relax, you’re not erasing tradition—you’re polishing it.

How to Pitch It to the Family

Let’s be real—our families can be stubborn. The abuelas will raise an eyebrow. The tíos will joke. But here’s how to pitch it: Present this as “the holiday upgrade.” Let them know it’s still Puerto Rican at its heart, but with a modern chef’s touch. It’s about honoring tradition without repeating the struggle meals our ancestors were forced into.

• Health: “I want us all to actually enjoy the food without taking three naps and checking our sugar levels afterward.”

• Respect: “We’re honoring tradition, just modernizing it. Think of it as giving our food the spotlight it deserves.”

• Hosting Pride: “We deserve a table that looks like it belongs on a magazine cover. That’s how we're gonna show love in 2025.”

And here’s the kicker: once they taste it, they’ll see you’re not taking anything away—you’re adding flavor, freshness, and finesse.

Retiring the Old Holiday Menu: From “Slave Food” to Classy Puerto Rican Cuisine

Every year, like clockwork, the holidays roll in, and the kitchen becomes the battlefield. Turkey, pernil, arroz con gandules, pasteles—the classics. But let’s keep it real: so much of what we were taught to cook for Thanksgiving and Christmas came from survival food, born out of poverty, scraps, and colonizer rations. The love is there, yes—but the foundation? Heavy, greasy, salt-packed, and in many ways rooted in “slave food” traditions that don’t have to chain us down anymore.

This year, I’m daring myself—and my family—to switch things up. Not by abandoning tradition, but by evolving it. I want to upgrade my Puerto Rican holiday menu into something healthier, more refined, more intentional. Think about it: we can honor our ancestors while still saying, “Gracias, but we’re not stuck in 1890.”

Why the Upgrade?

For one, health. Diabetes, high blood pressure, cholesterol—these things run wild in our community, and the holidays only make it worse. Why not show love with food that nourishes, energizes, and still tastes amazing? Refined doesn’t mean bland; it means smarter cooking.

Second, class. Hosting is an art. If you can swap out “poor people’s” ingredients for fresher, finer ones, suddenly the same plate goes from “kitchen table” to “five-star.” Roasted root vegetables instead of canned corn. A turkey (or pernil) brined with fresh herbs and citrus instead of drowned in salt. Even a simple salad with pomegranate seeds and avocado can scream elegance without breaking your budget.

🎄Much like in the kitchen, mise en plase; have your pitch rock-solid and ready for rebuttals and ridicule. It's best to have your plans written down, even if it's scribbled. Show your fam your upgraded Puerto Rican Holiday Menu! (the following is for suggestive purposes, that is of course, if you see something that floats your boat)

Starters / Appetizers:

• Mini Ceviche Cups – Fresh shrimp or snapper, marinated in lime juice, cilantro, red onion, and mango, served in chic little cups.

• Roasted Veggie Tapas – Eggplant, zucchini, and peppers drizzled with olive oil and herbs.

• Plantain Chips with Avocado-Pomegranate Salsa – A lighter, elegant spin on tostones, with a jewel-toned salsa that pops on the table.
  

Main Proteins:

• Citrus-Herb Pernil (Roasted Pork Shoulder) – Marinated in orange, lime, garlic, and rosemary; slow-roasted until tender with a crisp top, but not drowning in salt or fat.

• Mojo-Rubbed Turkey Breast – If doing turkey, skip the whole dry bird; go with juicy brined breasts seasoned with sofrito + citrus.
  

Sides (Elevated Classics)

• Wild Rice Pilaf with Gandules, Cranberries & Almonds – A refined upgrade to arroz con gandules that looks gourmet and tastes holiday-rich.

• Roasted Root Vegetables with Garlic & Herbs – Yuca, batata, carrots, and beets tossed in olive oil and roasted until caramelized.

• Green Salad with Avocado, Pomegranate, and Citrus Vinaigrette – Fresh, bright, and a visual showstopper on the table.

• Pastelón Bites – Instead of a whole heavy pastelón, make mini individual portions layered with sweet plantain, lean ground turkey, and veggies.

Dessert:

• Flan de Coco with Dark Chocolate Shavings – Smooth, silky, not over-sweet, and looks elegant plated.

• Mini Tembleques (Coconut Puddings) – Served in glass shot glasses with a sprinkle of cinnamon.

• Guava & Cheese Puff Pastries – Flaky, bite-sized, refined, but still that Boricua comfort.

Drinks:

• Coquito Light – Coconut milk, a touch of almond milk, and less condensed milk—still creamy, but lighter.

• Sparkling Passionfruit Mocktail/Cocktail – Festive and refreshing, with or without rum.

Closing Thoughts

Puerto Rican food is soulful, rich, and powerful. But it doesn’t need to stay trapped in the narratives of poverty and colonial leftovers. This holiday season, I’m flipping the script. Out with the slave food mentality, in with a refined menu that celebrates who we are now—healthy, thriving, classy, and still undeniably Boricua and honestly, nothing says “Feliz Navidad” like serving tradition with a side of elevation.

Get In Touch:
adm@boujeeburke.com
grievances: hbic@boujeeburke.com

Full disclosure: Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, I earn a teeny-tiny commission (at no extra cost to you). It helps keep the lights on and the coffee flowing while I bring you legit promotions and handpicked gems—because nobody likes shady deals, least of all me. Please feel free to reach out for inquiries, feedback, or partnership opportunities. Boujee Burke is open to suggestions, & mutually beneficial partnerships.